TOK Essay Title 6: Are we too quick to assume that the most recent evidence is inevitably the strongest? Discuss with reference to the natural sciences and one other area of knowledge.
Natural Sciences
Questions to Ponder:
Does the pressure to publish new findings in scientific research inadvertently encourage a bias toward the most recent evidence?
What are the ethical implications of disregarding older, yet still relevant, scientific data?
My Strong Suggestions:
Defend Recency: Let’s face it, science evolves. New techniques and technologies enable us to observe phenomena more accurately than before. There’s merit in giving weight to the latest evidence.
Question Recency: But hold on a second. New doesn’t always mean better. Sometimes, what’s recent is simply fashionable or aligned with current funding streams. Don’t forget the enduring contributions of older research.
Real-Life Examples:
Advances in CRISPR technology may seem like the pinnacle of genetic research, but the foundation laid by earlier work in the Human Genome Project remains significant.
The retraction of initially promising but ultimately flawed studies, such as some fast-tracked COVID-19 treatments, serves as a warning against recency bias.
TOK Success Stories
Immerse yourself in TOK success stories that echo our commitment to IB excellence. Witness how our students, armed with TOK insights, navigate the essay titles with precision and flair. Your TOK success story awaits. Ready to script your own narrative of triumph? Click below to join a community that propels students toward academic achievement.
Are newer ethical theories inherently superior because they address contemporary issues?
Do classic ethical frameworks like utilitarianism or deontological ethics lose their potency over time?
My Strong Suggestions:
Champion Evolution: Ethical questions evolve with society. Current theories may be better suited to address issues like digital privacy, which didn’t even exist a century ago. So there’s value in the new.
Respect Time-Tested Wisdom: However, some ethical quandaries are as old as humanity itself. The age of an ethical theory doesn’t necessarily diminish its applicability or depth.
Real-Life Examples:
Contemporary bioethics tackles new challenges like gene editing and AI, but its foundation often lies in older philosophical traditions.
The continued use of the Golden Rule—an ethical guideline present in various forms across numerous cultures and eras—as a basic principle of morality.
Get In Touch
Personalized TOK Consultation
Unleash your TOK potential with a personalized consultation. Our experts understand the unique demands of TOK within the IB curriculum. Tailoring guidance to your strengths, we ensure your TOK essay reflects your intellectual prowess. Ready to shape your TOK destiny? Click below to schedule a consultation and embark on a transformative TOK journey.
